Fails videos

Funny videos

Loading player...

Racing Games and Clutch Pedals

Published on Nov 6, 2018 217,872 views

Which game implemented better the clutch?
Let's find out...

Please, support me and my work on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/viperconcept

Comments
  • falchulk
    falchulk 4 месяца назад (изменено) What? "Drown" the car? Nooo...it's because it cannot produce enough torque to get the car moving without increased fuel/air/rpms. You can easily do this with v8 and Diesel engines. This is actually taught in most performance driving schools. You are releasing the clutch too fast if you cannot do this on flat ground.
  • 7000mac
    7000mac 4 месяца назад I thought the same. if you release the clutch slowly the car should move, shouldnt?
  • Skynoff
    Skynoff 4 месяца назад @7000mac It does move. You don't really have to push the throttle while releasing the clutch to get rolling, however it makes you roll quicker. If you just release the clutch slowly you'll move anyway
  • Mach-77
    Mach-77 4 месяца назад @Skynoff and that thing isn't even simulated in assetto corsa or PC2. it is kinda simulated in iRacing, tho. but AC is the biggest joke about that. stop the car on an inclined road. like the corkscrew. but really, STOP the car. and then, release the brake. your car won't even move. now, put it in gear and slowly release the clutch to the biting point. the car will just "stall". biggest joke from AC
  • Skynoff
    Skynoff 4 месяца назад @Mach-77 Yup hahaa I find that unpleasent aswell. You'll always have to push the throttle to start rolling in AC.
  • Miscu
    Miscu 4 месяца назад @Skynoff it depends with thr car. For exaple, the clutch of the miura engages much more gently that a 312t one, and that's totally realistic: performance car have a very sensitive and small engaging point in order to make clutch loose less time on shifts and be much faster. Anyways, the fact that in ac slopes aren't considered when you're standing still is quite annoying (even if it doesn't change much when you're racing tho...)
  • Joe CHAHINE
    Joe CHAHINE 4 месяца назад @Miscu true that it depends on the car and the minimum RPM set (we call it avance ) example in driving school they tend to have the minimum RPM 1500 or more so that is u release the clutch without enough gas it won't turn off, it will use more fuel though. But some race cars have instant clutch more than an analogue one almost act like a click instead of a gradual link. (but i don't have much experience in this area so I won't pretend to know more)
  • youkofoxy
    youkofoxy 4 месяца назад Truth, I did "launched" a VW Voyage alchool without pressing the accelerator. But i do think it had some clutch slip.. i don't know. Even my father has like "You are doing it wrong son" I was like "Trust me, i got a plan" The the car move and his was like "hum?"
  • Vincent Desseyn
    Vincent Desseyn 4 месяца назад What every single game gets wrong is that even if you release the clutch as fast as you can, the car should jolt forward like irl, but every single one of them just kills the engine without moving the car a nanometer. Also released the clutch slowly should move the car a little or in the case of engines that have lots of torque at low rpm (high capacity NA V8's(/V10 from viper ;)) and diesels can set easily like this), however every game that I know (that doesn't autoclutch) doesn't simulate any of the above.
  • Yung Spirit
    Yung Spirit 4 месяца назад @Mach-77 It's probably due to trying to make good launching physics but it still sucks, shouldn't encounter it while actually playing tho
  • Mach-77
    Mach-77 4 месяца назад @Vincent Desseyn then you didn't try rFactor 2, iRacing and Project CARS 2. those 3 simulates the biting point. PC2 and rF2 even makes the car jolt a bit forward when you release the clutch with no brakes applied
  • Vincent Desseyn
    Vincent Desseyn 4 месяца назад @Mach-77 I don't own Rf2 since I don't have a decent pc, but good to know that there's at least one sim that gets it right. Thx for letting me know.
  • sergio hernandez
    sergio hernandez 4 месяца назад I can start a roll on my integra, granted I have to release the clutch retty slow
  • Camera Fly
    Camera Fly 4 месяца назад https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JU8-Cp2wBrY
  • TheInstrumentalism 552
    TheInstrumentalism 552 4 месяца назад not with extremely low torque cars. #experience
  • butaa.
    butaa. 4 месяца назад i can get moving without the gas pedal in my 1.3 suzuki, you don't need a v8 for that
  • TheInstrumentalism 552
    TheInstrumentalism 552 4 месяца назад @butaa. The difference is that you are the drift king
  • Jay Gamer
    Jay Gamer 4 месяца назад @butaa. No manual car needs gas to start moving. Only if you're not trying to roll at snails speed you gotta use the gas.
  • Tr0y Boi
    Tr0y Boi 4 месяца назад (изменено) Hm, it is easy to start move on a V8 or Diesel only because it is also easy to start move on any engine, excluding soviet russian cars xD For example, in my driving school I moved uphill on a 70hp fabia without opening throttle(10 degrees angle), only clutch. Should I say that on a flat ground it is much more easier?
  • falchulk
    falchulk 4 месяца назад @Tr0y Boi I did say flat ground. Honestly, I have never had an issue. Many videos from Europe state their small petrol cats have issues. I can understand low tq cars having a problem. You might consider your experience is limited...to your experience. What others have said should not be seen as a lie unless you have the same experience with a different outcome.
  • Eduardo Avila
    Eduardo Avila 4 месяца назад Not drown, but actually 'kill' the enginebut suddenlly putting too much "weight" on it.
  • falchulk
    falchulk 4 месяца назад @Eduardo Avila The engine can't make enough torque at idle to move the drivetrain with the wheels on the ground...which is absolutely related to weight. Which is what I said.
  • Eduardo Avila
    Eduardo Avila 4 месяца назад falchulk Yes exactly, but tecnically it stalls the engine, and in some more older engines i guess it could lead to drowning too, as the gas would be pumped but not burned when the engine dont have the speed to do the turn enough for continue running. I just made an additon to the comment, i didnt disagree
  • falchulk
    falchulk 4 месяца назад @Eduardo Avila Older engines used mechanical fuel pumps. If the engine stopped due to stalling, it did not flood the engine.
  • Eduardo Avila
    Eduardo Avila 4 месяца назад @falchulk But by the fact that their fuel distribution wasnt so precise, it could lead to that issue.
  • falchulk
    falchulk 4 месяца назад @Eduardo Avila Nah. In order to create that condition, you has to crank the engine over and over without it firing.
  • Eduardo Avila
    Eduardo Avila 4 месяца назад (изменено) ​@falchulk In a situation where the mistake happens like 2 times in a row, and the carburator isnt really well adjusted, it could happen. I recall that happening with my cousing when he tried to learn to drive my grandfather's old vw beetle. Possibly then it could have not been adjusted well, and in a certain time, maybe it wasnt too well, but it didnt see to run badly, nor have a bad fuel consumption.
  • falchulk
    falchulk 4 месяца назад @Eduardo Avila Again, that's 2 different issues.
  • T M S
    T M S 3 месяца назад @7000mac Also when starting without releasing the clutch, the car should move because of the starter. I once forgot to shift into neutral and almost rear ended the car in front of me.
  • Bill Bezos
    Bill Bezos 3 месяца назад Imma comment same thing
  • TooManyChoices1
    TooManyChoices1 3 месяца назад Skynoff Unless your car has zero torque it will go with just a slow clutch release... If it is a weak or torque-less engine it will need some help from the gas pedal to not “bog”...
  • TooManyChoices1
    TooManyChoices1 3 месяца назад butaa. Nope but you do need torque. If the engine has no torque off idle then it’s dead without some throttle input.
  • bubberlad
    bubberlad 2 месяца назад Not just performance schools, most driving schools teach this. Where I live you are first tought to drive only with the clutch and then you move on to the actual gas pedal. I cannot fathom how terrible driving a manual in traffic would be if you had to bolt off with the gas pedal everytime you wanted to lift off.
  • Skids
    Skids 2 месяца назад He also considered heel toe pressing the clutch and then dropping it with out going down a gear or pressing the brake at the same time. Clearly doesnt know much of what hes talking about
  • Gen PS3
    Gen PS3 1 месяц назад Mach-77 i can move the car in pc2 without pushing the throttle
  • treerexaudi Official
    treerexaudi Official 4 месяца назад Wanna here a joke? Forza Horizon 4 clutch c:
  • budaroddy
    budaroddy 4 месяца назад Hear
  • DobieMeltfire
    DobieMeltfire 4 месяца назад Surprising Forza Motorsport (I'm not sure which, I think it's FM3) has a really good clutch system including clutch damage. I'm not sure if it still apply for FM7 since the physic has been simplify for... ahem... Horizon racers.
  • Victor galvão barreto
    Victor galvão barreto 4 месяца назад FM7 is like Project cars, even turned off, it still shifts with no problem at all, sad
  • Abel Eva
    Abel Eva 4 месяца назад The problem here is you have to press the clutch very Hard xD
  • Odriannggues
    Odriannggues 4 месяца назад (изменено) @DobieMeltfire Ah yes, the dastardly Horizon players. They are the scum of the earth for they play an arcade game. If I came across as an arsehole, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to. It's just that your reaction to the thought of Horizon racers was a bit silly, but I think it's perfectly fine if you don't like Horizon.
  • Xavalin Trademark
    Xavalin Trademark 4 месяца назад OrangeDingus And what about me? I play both Simulation and Arcade car Games (specially Assetto Corsa and Forza Horizon 4) Sometimes the "simplicity" of arcade games is quite fun...
  • treerexaudi Official
    treerexaudi Official 4 месяца назад agreed and same here c: @Xavalin Trademark
  • DeadJuice
    DeadJuice 4 месяца назад do you wanna hear a good joke Forza Motorsport 7
  • Lucas Tekkan
    Lucas Tekkan 4 месяца назад @Xavalin Trademark Assetto is not a simulator
  • souldry
    souldry 4 месяца назад Lucas Tekkan Yes, it is.
  • a cunt
    a cunt 4 месяца назад DeadJuice do you want to hear a more specific joke? multiplayer clean racing
  • Xavalin Trademark
    Xavalin Trademark 4 месяца назад Lucas Tekkan So what it is? A potato??
  • anil jadhav
    anil jadhav 4 месяца назад FIA my butt, GTS.
  • E3 V Ghost
    E3 V Ghost 4 месяца назад @DobieMeltfire yes it is FM3
  • Stormtrooper1845
    Stormtrooper1845 4 месяца назад @a cunt that's a good one!
  • Stormtrooper1845
    Stormtrooper1845 4 месяца назад @Lucas Tekkan what is it then?
  • Camera Fly
    Camera Fly 4 месяца назад https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JU8-Cp2wBrY
  • ItsBozzy
    ItsBozzy 4 месяца назад Not sure if anyone else has this in FH4, but when i press the clutch in neutral it makes a gear grinding sound :D
  • brody of hillcountry
    brody of hillcountry 4 месяца назад @Victor galvão barreto Are you sure? If you check the telemetry in FM6 you can see the clutch/transmission damage in percent form.
  • Victor galvão barreto
    Victor galvão barreto 4 месяца назад @brody of hillcountry last time i tried FM7 it was like that, driving a mustang, changing gears without pressing clutch, but thst game does not accept more than 600 rotation, so never played it on the wheel anymore, i do not jow if they changed it
  • KIM JONG FAT
    KIM JONG FAT 4 месяца назад @Lucas Tekkan is it a fuck simulator?
  • Davie Box
    Davie Box 4 месяца назад Go watch TheSLAP Train
  • Davie Box
    Davie Box 4 месяца назад He’s good with the clutch when he drifts
  • TunedS2K
    TunedS2K 4 месяца назад Ohhh yess
  • Seribean44
    Seribean44 4 месяца назад @Odriannggues I like horizon as a laid back game but I prefer assetto corsa which is full simulation and I think its a good game
  • Odriannggues
    Odriannggues 4 месяца назад Okay... I think some people might not have realised I was being super sarcastic. I love Horizon. It's a great franchise to sit down and chill out playing. I am, first and foremost, an arcade racer myself. The ONLY true simulation game I have is BeamNG.Drive xd You're fine to me if you like sim games, you're fine to me if you like arcade games, you're fine to me if you don't even like games.
  • Jean
    Jean 4 месяца назад This right here! The "Manua w/ clutch" option is a complete joke.
  • treerexaudi Official
    treerexaudi Official 4 месяца назад this is still poppin woah xD@Jean
  • Mergy
    Mergy 4 месяца назад grinding of clutch intensifies
  • Eduardo Avila
    Eduardo Avila 4 месяца назад None of these games can get over beamngdrive clutch system
  • ElteeMullet
    ElteeMullet 3 месяца назад The clutch works the same as most other games, bad. Horizon destroys every other game in graphics, cars, fun factor... The only thing it lacks is VR support. The clutch could be better but at the same time could also be a lot worse. GT sport looks worse than need for speed shift 2 on pc. Id worry more about that than a clutch thats not perfect.